香港獨立媒體 - Comments for "必需品"

正!

花苑, 妳好. 睇左你d畫作好耐, 請問收唔收學生或者開班呀. 有既話, 通知聲呀. 新年快樂!

Don't know

I am just using laser as an example to illustrate art is independent from the tool that used to create the art. It's stupidity uneconomical to use laser to create a print while you can use much cheaper tools.

Re: Mt. Yes. Once you formula art into a form, art cease to be an art. The essence of art is that it has no form. Forms are just categories created by us for the sake of management.

誰說一定要版畫（一笑）

What's important is what the 版畫 trying to express. If you achieve the same expression and communicate to the audience, a fart is as good as a 版畫.

Clarify: If the above statement were true, then we shall need no art forms --mt respects the creation as well as the expression of every art form, and hence doesn't buy such idea.

(Edited after Ken Ho's comment -- 1. corrected a word; 2. added lines to clarify intent.)

If...

mt and hevangel:
"If you archive the same expression and communicate to the audience..."
Isn't that the key question. And also... why use laser when a piece of metal would do? And if you can't even get a right piece of metal to do the job, what are the chances that you can get a more complicated piece of technology to do the same thing.

And oh, I think you guys mean "achieve" not "archive".

毛筆鍋子也只是工具

毛筆有軟有硬﹐是因為要寫出不同風格的書法。寫出來的書法表達的東西是目的﹐毛筆只是達到這個目的的工具。若果發明一枝新款毛筆﹐可以同時集合軟硬毛筆的功用﹐寫出來的書法也沒有分別的話﹐毛筆根本不需要分軟硬。

誰說版畫一定要用刀刻﹖用電腦繪圖加鐳射切割也可以整版畫。

只用鍵盤的人當然不知毛筆有軟有硬鍋子有平有圓

是的花苑。我每回在台灣和日本逛美術用品店，都只有羨慕的份兒。我不迷信所謂民族性，但日本在現代代過程中以德國為師，二者對技藝的注重體現在對每一個細節的嚴緊追求。看Durer的銅版與浮世繪，就知道利害。而技法到了爐火純青忘其所以之後就是道了。到了這個階段，才談用菜刀刻版畫未遲。
無錢去日本，下回到台，記得幫你帶點材料。

re: ken

I took the philosophy of art. I disagree with the formalism art theory. For the definition of art, I am an expressionist. In response to your question, whether the paint use oil or water is irrelevant, what's important is what the painting trying to express. If you archive the same expression and communicate to the audience, a laser printer painting is as good as a oil painting.

"板畫不過是一個外在的形式"?

I disagree. That's kind of like saying oil paintings and water paintings are the same because they both use colour. I am in engineering by training so I probably can't appreciate the subject as much as those from anthropology, but I thought 形式 is often a very important part of culture and tradition. Is hevangel suggesting we should just make art on computer and use laser printer?

網上訂購

上網買野咁方便﹐香港美術店沒有得賣﹐網上郵寄訂購不就可以了嗎﹖

板畫不過是一個外在的形式﹐文化並不拘泥於門面的形式﹐而是著重內在的思維與行動模式。香港其實有自己的文化和傳統﹐只是你置身其中不易察覺罷了。你如果在外國讀過有很多留學生的大學﹐有機會將不同文化背景的人並排比較﹐香港人是有一套很獨特的文化﹐同大陸人台灣人很不相同。

好奇一問﹐點解你要作板畫﹖是興趣還是工作需要﹖