題為編輯所擬。
江永祥「解釋」點解以阻差辦公罪拘捕記者,啲 law 100% 錯撚晒,痴撚線。
1. 'The officers in question were in uniform, so the reporter should have had no reasonable suspicion about their identities.'
2. 'Asking the officers to show warrant card was not a reasonable excuse for not showing her identity card.'
我重申,時任最高法院高等法院法官梁紹中在 R v Lau Yin Kum (unreported, HCMA 15/1997, 23 May 1997) 案判詞第3頁裁定,市民有權要求任何當值的警員(無論是否身穿制服)展示委任證以供核實及辨識其身份。
在此原則下,因要求身穿制服、膊頭有 number(何況無?)的警員展示委任證不果,而拒絕出示身分證,不屬阻差辦公。







