衰觀眾
週一, 2005-09-19 20:17 — sevenine
昨天看了《梁祝下世傳奇》，實在精彩。但由於我的膚淺，基於我只是一個門外漢，我不敢亦不會在此評論此舞台劇。（忍不住以門外漢的身份膚淺地讚兩句：故事寫得動人，演員演得精采）
此劇固然於各方面的水準也不俗，我認為唯一的問題就是「衰觀眾」。此際我不禁想起《買兇拍人》內的李棟全（即張達明）的一句：「香港嘅電影正正就係衰喺呢個環節……」
我不知是否我自己的問題，是否我已經跟社會脫節，有一些我認為並非笑位的場面，卻聽見哄堂大笑。正面一點的，可以稱這群觀眾「有反應」，但不分青紅皂白地笑，是否過了點火呢？
可惜，某些場面的細節我忘掉了，或者不甚肯定，故未能寫出來讓諸看官自行判斷，然而，希望各位有看此劇的人出來分享對此事之看法，好讓小弟知道自己是否有問題。
p.s.有兩個「可能笑位」是如此的：
一，祖自白時說，自己小時看梁祝會想到一個問題：「若然一個變了蜻蜓的話如何？」然後就聽見笑聲，我不否認這可能引人發笑，但真的有這麼好笑嗎？
二，祖後來跟言說：「我現在變了一隻蜻蜓呀！」然後又聽見笑聲，這次比較正常，但我認為只是一個比喻，亦未至於要「笑出聲」。
p.p.s.有一處我完全不明白為何要笑的場面如下：
前後的經過我記得不清楚了，我只記得兩男相擁時有人發笑，實在不明所以。
p.p.s.謹希望有人可以出來解答，以釋小弟之疑惑。
回應
I am a typical example
I would cry or laugh 'over-reactively' in certain places, even when most other people don't think that we should laugh or cry or scream. It is a kind of sensation and an excitement, normally links to the past experience and imaginations of the people. Like in some movies, when a lot of people are very sad, I couldn't stop myself from laughing. You really can't blame people because of their past experience.
By the way, when watching Lord of the Ring III, I cried like mad and screamed a few times, I knoew somebody thought that I was mad, but it was too touching for me in several scenes. We cannot judge the others' value judgements without knowing their value judgements. I just hope that no mobile phone rings throughout a concert, a movie, a play, a musical, etc., etc.
即係呢...
...就算係喊得好勁...同有少少眼淚...都係喊o者....不過而家我講o既唔係「笑得好勁」同「少少笑」o既分別....而係o係o的唔係笑位o既位笑...咁...又算唔算係一種膚淺呢?
「We cannot judge the others' value judgements without knowing their value judgements.」
So,are you judging my judgements?
(Actually it's okay to judge me,but the sentense seems to be a paradox...)